PPC vs Organic Search: Which is better for local Traffic?
Posted by Jan at 4:39 pm
Which is better for local Traffic: PPC ( pay per click) or
Organic Search engine optimization?
When I speak to local businesses and mention that I am an internet marketer I normally get questions about my web designs or pay per click advertising finesse. The irony is I do very little of either.
PPC Google advertising vs Organic Atlanta Local search results
While each has its pros and cons here is the basic lowdown:
SEO takes longer to get results, but your Local Search efforts bring a higher quality of prospect and last for a longer period of time. These click convert better because people trust organic listings 86% of the time. They also click more frequently on top organic listings.
PPC is quick - you can begin to get results very quickly. The downside is that it is highly competitive and it can be very expensive as the demand for it has risen sharply in the past year. For example, the term “Atlanta movers” is now going for over $10 a click! Plus, as soon as you stop paying, you lose every bit of that traffic forever. We always favor organic Search because it pays more in the long run.
I prefer to optimize website and business profiles for organic ranking. (meaning they show up without you having to pay Google to show them) I do this for two main reasons:
1) Organic listings get better click through rates and higher conversion. This means that more people click on and trust the naturally highest ranking websites. In many industries paid advertising is completely ignored. Eye tracking has shown that peoples eyes literally stay away from the paid advertisements and stay on the headlines and content of organic results.
2) Organic rankings often last longer and build upon each other. Having pages that rank high for natural search can increase link juice to other pages and phrases (when done properly) But they can also drain page rank if done haphazardly.
Organic traffic lasts longer & brings quality customers
We only do organic SEO. Your business will organically outrank the competition using the organic marketing techniques we have researched and tested. Many SEO companies get you quick rankings by running PPC campaigns, but all this really means is that you are paying for internet advertising, once you quit paying there is no more traffic.
PPC Local Results can be expensive and disappointing
Often PPC costs are ridiculously high and the conversions are dismal. Many local companies have tried running their own Adwords campaigns and have no idea how much more effective (not to mention less expensive) Local search optimization and directory submission can be.
There are also plenty of inexperienced PPC marketers who over bid on high competition words forcing you to pay a fortune for bad leads. Don’t forget the unscrupulous folks who will run up your adwords bill by repeatedly clicking their competitors ads. (this is called click fraud) Keep in mind: Google does NOT care if you EVER get a single customer off of Adwords – they will happily take your money anyway.
We don’t pay for Placement or use unethical or black hat tactics
We don’t use paid advertising (PPC) to rank your website or employ black hat tactics; because they will not get you the long terms results you need to stay in business. Plus they could get your listings deleted and your website banned.
Beware of PPC and Guaranteed top rank Scams
Be aware that there are many SEO SCAMS. Marketing companies that guarantee TOP Google listings are often boldly lying to you. Getting #1 on Google often means you will be paying for adwords or you are getting top placement for keywords no one searches with. So please do yourself a favor and get ALL of the details. I had one client who paid $1000 a month for “guaranteed top Google placement” for 2 keyword phrases. All the company did was bid $30 a click for the two terms (which meant they always showed up at the top) They spend maybe $350 a month on the clients adwords campaign and pocketed the rest.
Why- Because the 2 terms, although they sounded good, did not get significant search traffic. A somewhat shady way to guarantee top Google placement – Note: these results did not get this client any business!
Being organic is good for business:
Organic Local search programs are more cost effective and the results last longer than PPC or print advertising. With online marketing, Atlanta businesses get a higher return for money spent and attract customers who are more likely to buy.
Maximum leverage with long term benefits
The added bonus of organic search ranking is that these SEO placements last for months and even years and they build upon each other, creating an impenetrable marketing advantage. We understand that you need your customers to find your business information prominently featured when they do an internet search for your goods and services. We believe that the best way to achieve this goal is through organic search engine optimization.
Local internet advertising is the most effective when combined with Local directory submission, an enhanced business profile and links from micro local blogs and directories (like city blogs, chamber of commerce sites etc) The factors that matter for ranking in Local are totally different from those that matter for ranking universally
Updated Local Business listings in local directories is essential
Local consumers use a variety of online sources including search engines like Google, Yahoo and Bing, as well as directory type sites like Yellow pages, Kudzu, and Yelp to dig up local information. These business listings should be well optimized and frequently updated for optimum results. Leaving out even one important detail could lead customers (and search engines) to choose a competitor with a better optimized listing.
Local Business reviews and social relevancy counts
Customers want to know what other people think about your business before they do business with you – this is why reviews and social bookmarking can be so harmful or beneficial to your success. Instead of being afraid of user reviews – encourage them and reap the benefits of more local search exposure and more local foot traffic.
Successful local internet advertising means being MORE relevant
Quality customers come from high organic search results because that is what people trust. This also indicates that your pages and content are relevant to what people are searching for. This high level of relevancy is a huge factor in pre-selling your customers on doing business with you. Think about it, people naturally trust recommendations over ads, and in a very real sense, that is why organic listings garner a higher level of trust.
Local Internet marketing pays off.
Having a strong Local internet search and advertising program is essential to the success of your Atlanta business and best of all it costs less than print advertising, PPC (Pay per click advertising) or Yellow pages ads and produces better results because it allows real local customers to connect with you. Without a local business marketing plan you could be missing hundred or even thousands of new customers a month – yes even in this economy!
Go here to see examples of recent Local Atlanta Search numbers by industry.